Postby scy » Tue Sep 30, 2008 3:29 am
Meh, I like Melee more just due to me being better at some of the mechanics (aerials, fast falls, L-cancels, waveshine/dash etc). That said, I find Brawl a bit more fair on characters (though the Sheik dair being terrible makes me sad and the Jigglypuff nerfs) so whatever ... though a good Wolf is lame imo (and why I love Wolf since I'm so fucking cheap with him~).
I completely disagree on the game being "bland" or anything of the sort at the 1v1 "tourneyfag" level. The sheer level of stuff going on more than makes up for the "loss" of items. Nor is it "like Tekken." I personally can't even stand Tekken, Soul Calibur, or any of those but find the Smash Bros. games fucking awesome. They're very, very different games (if only due to the vast amounts of mobility involved).
I have no problems with items but I find them stupid; a well timed Pokeball or Assist Trophy or Final Smash or fucking anything, really, can turn the tide one way or the other; not a "waaah items is why I lost" either as I'm pretty good at catching items thrown at me or reflecting with shield (or Reflector since I normally use Wolf). I just like having no "random" elements IN ONE ON ONE MATCHES. I can play with items and all that jazz but it's just "not serious," and goofing off kind of things. That's all. A bunch of us playing and drinking and the sheer mayhem is awesome but when we want some serious "technical" matches, 1v1, no items, FD.
Also, some stages are just stupid retarded (Flat Zone 2 can burn in fucking hell).