Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 9:54 pm
That's a different situation entirely, however. This situation is "atheist celebrating religious Holiday = hypocritical." This has nothing to do with "but what if you take the religion out of it?!?!" or anything of that nature as you're not celebrating that Holiday anymore. Don't stretch the situation to some unrelated areas. All that matters is "religious Holiday + Atheist = hypocrite." That's the issue, not the "spirit of the Holiday" or any of that; the physical (as it were) Holiday is of religious background and to observe it when you deny the religion it has it's roots in is hypocritical.
Edit: For example, it is equally hypocritical if atheists were to celebrate Easter, Ramadan (...celebrate), Chanukah/Hanukkah, etc. due to the religious foundation of them. If you deny a religion itself, anything that stems from it should just be as denied.
[spoiler]It's hypocritical to be against alcohol, for example, but you're fine with drinking on any Holiday/Celebration. It's hypocritical to be against smoking but be fine with marijuana.
Hypocrisy is merely to state to believe something yet do the opposite. I'm rather confused how you can argue that "someone who doesn't believe in religion celebrates a religion" isn't a case of hypocrisy. It isn't "atheist therefore they must destroy Christmas for everyone" but just pointing out that they're being hypocrites; they can observe Christmas out of respect for friends/family/etc. but to go all out and celebrate it yourself is a different manner.
Edit: To give a better non-religion example, I have friends that do not condone drinking at all but it isn't hypocritical for them to be around me and my other friends who are raging alcoholics; it would, however, be hypocritical for them to then throw a party for drinking. [/spoiler]
Edit: For example, it is equally hypocritical if atheists were to celebrate Easter, Ramadan (...celebrate), Chanukah/Hanukkah, etc. due to the religious foundation of them. If you deny a religion itself, anything that stems from it should just be as denied.
[spoiler]It's hypocritical to be against alcohol, for example, but you're fine with drinking on any Holiday/Celebration. It's hypocritical to be against smoking but be fine with marijuana.
Hypocrisy is merely to state to believe something yet do the opposite. I'm rather confused how you can argue that "someone who doesn't believe in religion celebrates a religion" isn't a case of hypocrisy. It isn't "atheist therefore they must destroy Christmas for everyone" but just pointing out that they're being hypocrites; they can observe Christmas out of respect for friends/family/etc. but to go all out and celebrate it yourself is a different manner.
Edit: To give a better non-religion example, I have friends that do not condone drinking at all but it isn't hypocritical for them to be around me and my other friends who are raging alcoholics; it would, however, be hypocritical for them to then throw a party for drinking. [/spoiler]